Your Email Marketing Strategy Matters More Than Ever
A newsletter is the one place where you don’t have to rely on a platform that could change the rules tomorrow. That’s why your email marketing strategy matters more than ever.
Remember when the Google Search Bar was the reliable on-ramp to everything digital? Yeah. That’s changing.
The new Google Search bar—the one that answers questions directly before you even click through—is crushing the organic traffic that small and medium businesses used to count on. Your SEO strategy? Still matters. But the path to your website just got a lot longer. And that means the old playbook—”build traffic, convert visitors, cross your fingers”—isn’t cutting it anymore.
Here’s what is: owned channels. Specifically, newsletters.
A newsletter is the one place on the internet where you don’t have to compete with an algorithm, a search bar, or a platform that could change the rules tomorrow. You own it. Your subscribers opted in. They’re expecting to hear from you.
For business owners and service providers, your newsletter is a central business development strategy.
🌿 🌿 🌿 🌿 🌿
The Newsletter Is a Relationship Tool
Most small businesses approach newsletters wrong. They think “email list = sales pipeline” and start writing “buy my thing” every week.
But people don’t opt in to buy. They opt in to stay connected to someone or something they care about.
If your newsletter contains nothing but asks—buy, donate, sign up, register—your unsubscribe rate will tell you the real story. What your subscribers want is something better: curiosity, insider access, a sense that they’re part of something worth paying attention to. Here’s how:
- Make it worth subscribing to. Not “subscribe for updates.” But “subscribe to get the one thing we don’t post anywhere else.” Staff picks. Behind-the-scenes thinking. First look at what’s coming. A perspective you can’t find in your Instagram feed.
- Repeat the message. It takes multiple touchpoints for someone to remember you exist. Some say seven is the minimum number of times you need to communicate. Some estimate that’s gotten higher. What everyone agrees upon: repetition works. How many emails did you get from your favorite brand this week?
- Use human language. If your newsletter reads like it was written by a corporation, you’ve already lost. Have it come from a real person. Use first-person language. Share original thinking. The personal touch is what converts subscribers into customers (or fans, or collaborators, depending on your goal).
- Show gratitude. When someone subscribes, they’re giving you something valuable. Their attention. That’s a vote of confidence. Your information is important to them. Don’t take that lightly. Write a welcome email and make it count. A real thank you from a real person—not a “do not reply” address—signals that you’re paying attention to them too.
➤ Read More: Stop optimizing for time savings. AI’s real superpower is turning your gold mine of disconnected business infointo a competitive edge.
🌿 🌿 🌿 🌿 🌿
What’s Your Sizzle?
Everyone has an unfair advantage. Does AI understand yours?
Enter your URL. Get your five-page Sizzle Scan analysis.
How AI Makes Email Marketing Sustainable (Without Burning You Out)
Yes, building a newsletter that feels personal, consistent, and valuable takes time. Time most businesses don’t have. But AI can help you level the playing field.
You can use AI to:
- Speed up the writing. Not to replace your voice—but to help you get ideas out of your head and onto the page faster. Outline, rough draft to AI. Final draft, you. Claude AI can handle the scaffolding so you can focus on the thinking.
- Personalize at scale. With the help of AI, you can segment your list based on what subscribers care about and tailor the message accordingly.
- Stay consistent. AI can help you batch-write weeks of newsletters in one session. That way you’re not scrambling every Thursday at 5 p.m. wondering what to say.
- Analyze what’s working. AI can pull data from your email metrics and help you spot patterns—which topics drive opens, which CTAs convert, where subscribers are your most valuable.
- Connect directly. Claude AI now has native connections (MCPs) to connect directly into email platforms like Kit.com and Gmail. That means you can build AI-powered workflows right inside Claude that pull subscriber data, draft personalized messages, or analyze performance—without jumping betwen tools.
Think of using AI as having a very knowledgeable but rowdy research assistant + copywriter + data analyst all in one place. You bring the strategy and voice. The AI handles the heavy lifting.
People don’t opt in to buy. They opt in to stay connected to someone or something they care about.
– Monica Poling
🌿 🌿 🌿 🌿 🌿
The Strategy First, Tools Second
When you’re using AI for email: the strategy has to come first. Before you ask AI to write anything, you need to answer these questions:
- Why are you sending this newsletter? (Be specific. “Stay in touch” doesn’t count.)
- Who are you sending it to? (Not “everyone.” What do your best subscribers care about?)
- What’s in it for your subscribers? (What’s the thing-your known for-they can’t find anywhere else?)
- What do you get out of it? (Trust, relationship, data for what’s next, sales down the line—whatever it is, name it.)
Once you kinow those answers, AI becomes a force multiplier. Without defining this first, you’re just using AI to do the wrong thing faster.
🌿 🌿 🌿 🌿 🌿
Own the Channel
You can expect algorithms to keep shifting and social media reach to narrow even more. That’s why your email list is your competitive advantage. Remember to treat it like the it’s the valuable tool it is.
Build your relationships first. Your customers are looking to you to guide them. Make your newsletter about connection, not just conversion. Focus on growing the list before you focus on selling. A warm, engaged list of 500 people is worth more than a cold list of 5,000.
Use AI to make it sustainable. Claude + MCPs can help you go from “this newsletter is drowning me” to “this newsletter is helping grow my business.” Faster drafts. Better data. Less context-switching.
🌿 🌿 🌿 🌿 🌿
The Bottom Line
Stop treating your newsletter as a sales tool and start treating it as a relationship builder. AI doesn’t replace the work; it makes it sustainable by handling drafting, analysis, and personalization so you can focus on strategy and voice.
Key Takeaways
- Newsletters are survival, not sales. In a post-algorithm world, owned channels are your only guarantee of reach.
- People opt in to your newsletter for connection, not conversion. Make your newsletter worth reading first, and sales will follow naturally.
- Strategy before tools. Know why you’re sending, who you’re sending to, what they get, and what you get. Then AI becomes a force multiplier.
- AI handles the friction. Speed, consistency, personalization, analysis—Claude + MCPs turn newsletters from a side hustle drain into a real business asset.
🌿 🌿 🌿 🌿 🌿
Work with Me
Ask the
Expert
Turn your organizational knowledge into your biggest business asset
Most businesses have incredible expertise — but that knowledge is buried in emails, documents, and people’s heads — their website barely scratches the surface. That gap quietly costs leads, sales, and trust. Ask the Expert turns your expertise into a 24/7 AI-powered search engine and knowledge base.
Data on Tap
AI-Generated Biz Tools
Imagine how AI can visualize your expertise (and collect leads)
Data on Tap is a growing collection of AI-powered intelligence visualization tools that turn your knowledge into an interactive playground — data visualizations, calculators, and more. Using AI, you can build most of these tools in an afternoon. Follow along as I show you how. (Or contact me to build one for you.)
AI Workshops for
Organizations & Teams
Practical AI for better decision making.
AI is reshaping every industry — but most of today’s training focuses on tools. My interactive sessions start with strategy – where is your business feeling friction and how can you use AI to organize, share and monetize your knowledge. Customizable for large and small groups.
Speaking &
Keynotes
Start with your Unfair Advantage
Most businesses can’t track where their revenue actually comes from — or where it’s quietly leaking out. These keynotes and sessions show audiences how to map their revenue, close the gap between strategy and execution, and use AI as a real thinking partner along the way. You leave with frameworks you can deploy Monday morning.
🌿 🌿 🌿 🌿 🌿
Email Marketing Mistakes Made by Tourism Pros
Dive into our strategies on how to beat some of the most common email marketing mistakes made by tourism pros.
Relationship Marketing Means Building Relationships
Having a robust email list is your best, easiest way to create buzz for your activities, events, and offers. A strong email list also allows you to nurture subscribers on your terms and your schedule. Build a marketing strategy that prioritizes relationships, and you’ll turn subscribers into loyal, passionate advocates who genuinely connect with what you offer.
The Mistakes Marketers Make
Relationship-building is crucial in cultural tourism marketing, but the reality is that many marketers struggle to effectively communicate and connect with their audience. Enter email marketing. Now entering its fifth decade—yes, that’s right, email marketing is now 50 years old—email marketing continues to be the most effective way to build an audience and to create long-term, meaningful relationships for your destination, experience or cultural offering.
While email marketing has evolved over the past five decades, the ways we use email to promote our services have not kept up. Many marketers fall into the trap of making common, avoidable mistakes. These missteps can inadvertently hinder you efforts to foster genuine relationships with potential visitors, partners, and culture bearers.
The good news? With a few adjustments, these email marketing pitfalls are easy to avoid. Let’s take a look at some of the most common email marketing mistakes in cultural tourism—and how you can avoid them so you can turn your email strategy into a powerful tool for building deeper, lasting connections.
Common Email Marketing Mistakes
Mistake #1: Not Sending a Thank You to New Subscribers
By signing up, new subscribers have taken an action—an action that thousands of businesses are competing to receive. These subscribers have provided you with a vote of confidence—a thumbs up that tells you your arts or tourism experience is worth supporting. Capturing their attention is no small feat—getting them to share their email is even more difficult. Ignoring this gesture is like snubbing guests at a holiday party.
What to Do Instead: When someone subscribes to your list, don’t just send a standard “Thank you for subscribing, click here to confirm your email” response. Send a personal thank you. Make new subscribers feel appreciated right off the bat. Your thank you email (or landing page) should include links to some of your “greatest hits” website content. This not only builds rapport but can also increase your website page views—double bonus.
Mistake #2: Not Personalizing Emails
Nobody wants to feel like they’re just another name on a list. Starting an email with “Dear <empty field>” is a major misstep. “Dear <preferred guest>” or “Dear <awesome person>” isn’t much better.
What to Do Instead: Require subscriber give you their first name in all your forms and landing pages. Also, regularly audit your email list to ensure personalization, especially if you manually add subscribers. Then, use the first name field throughout your email. Not just in the greeting, but also add the field to your subject lines and throughout your email body copy to foster a real connection.
Also remember, personalization is a two-way street. Brand your emails from a person, not from a generic “organization” account. Have your email comes from your CEO, tribal chairman, curator, or visitor services pro. Personalizing the “sender” makes subscribers feel like they’re interacting with a human, a guide to your organization if you will, and not another faceless corporate entity.
People Follow People
Richard Branson’s approachable storytelling and charismatic presence attract millions of followers. Case in point: His personal Instagram account welcomes nearly five million followers. Virgin on the other hand, welcomes a *mere* 248 thousand followers. People connect with people—not businesses.
Mistake #3: Not Having a Friendly Welcome Sequence
When someone subscribes to your email list, that’s when they’re most excited to learn about what you do. So, give them that immediate “dopamine hit” they’re looking for. Don’t make them wait 30 days to hear from you.
4,500 Emails Later…
People receive nearly 150 emails a day. If it takes your organization 30 days to send your “first” email, that’s 4,500 emails later for your subscribers. By the time they hear from you, they may well have forgotten why they subscribed in the first place.
What to Do Instead: Set up an automated welcome sequence that kicks off immediately after they subscribe. Start with a heartfelt thank you email that mirrors the language on your thank you page. Then follow up with a series of emails tailored to their interests. You can share information about when and why to visit your destination or facility, a list of upcoming events, or send them links to the top content on your site. A sequence of about four emails over two weeks is a good cadence to keep your subscribers engaged and to keep you and your organization top of mind.
Mistake #4: Not Segmenting Your Lists
Common marketing advice says “know your audience” and focus on one key target audience. That is not great advice for the hospitality industry – especially cultural tourism – where we must attract and nurture visitors, tour operators, meeting planners, the media, and local stakeholders. Each of of these target segments have very different requirements. While a one-size fit’s all newsletter is better than no communication at all, targeted lists that speak directly to your audience needs.
What to Do Instead: Make sure your newsletter marketing strategy includes list segments and tags, so you can send the right message to the right person.
Mistake #5: Giving New Subscribers Too Many “List” Options
There’s a fine line between choice and overwhelm. While *you* may have many internal email segments, you should not bombard your subscribers with endless list options. Your culture umbrella list, Midwest madness list, and frenzy flywheel list means very little to subscribers. What’s more, too many list choices can drive them away from subscribing due to fear they’ll be bombarded with too many emails.
What to Do Instead: Offer one clear main list—your monthly or weekly update. Then create different sign up forms depending on the page from which people are subscribing. If they subscribe from your press room, for example, offer two lists – your main list and your media list. If they subscribe from your grant age, give them the option of your main list and your grant list. You can also use link triggers within your email content to autosubscribe current subscribers to new lists. This makes your sign-up process less overwhelming while also ensuring subscribers get content they actually care about.
What is a Link Trigger?
A Link Trigger is a link that has backend code that automatically triggers an action (or multiple actions) as soon as a subscriber clicks that link.
For example, if a subscriber clicks a “Grant Deadline” link, you could “tag” them to automatically be enrolled in your funding newsletter – or they could automatically receive an email asking if they’d like to be added to that list.
Mistake #6: Not Offering a Sign-Up Incentive
People get too many emails—that’s a fact. Even the most intrepid traveler or arts connoisseur will think twice about signing up for yet another email list. So give people a reason to sign up. Offer something extra—a sign-up incentive or “lead magnet”—to motivate more subscriptions.
What to Do Instead: Provide a clear and valuable sign-up incentive for new subscribers. This could be a special discount, a packing checklist, a local recipe booklet, or an insider secrets guide. “Did You Know Quizzes” also work very well in attracting sign ups and capturing emails. Not only do incentives help you get more subscribers, but when set up correctly, they can also help you learn more about what your visitors are looking for.
Mistake #7: Not Building Community
Your subscribers aren’t just numbers—they’re people with real interests, dreams, and aspirations. Failing to engage with their needs makes it harder to build relationships. So think of your email list as a valued community instead of a series of numbers and open rate metrics.
What to Do Instead: Use your emails to cultivate a sense of belonging. Offer exclusive content for subscribers. Provide behind-the-scenes updates or early access to local events. Also, poll your subscribers to understand why they signed up and what their interests are. Then, continue to segment your list to deliver precisely the content they want.
Mistake #8: Only Emailing When You Have Something to Sell
People don’t want to be constantly sold to. They want to be inspired, educated, and entertained. Yes, they’re willing to hear a sales pitch now and again, but only if you’ve already built a relationship with them as a trusted source.
What to Do Instead: Create a strong content plan that engages your audience—share freebies, bonuses, insider looks, and stories. Highlight the people behind your organization and community, and offer behind-the-scenes glimpses. When you inspire your audience, they’re far more likely to support you when you do ask them to pull out their wallets.
Mistake #9: Ignoring Replies from Subscribers
Many email marketers, especially in the arts and tourism industries, still send emails from unmonitored accounts. The thinking is—perhaps—that personal replies may overwhelm the system or cause a breakdown in operations, but this is a mistake.
What to Do Instead: Allow people to respond to your emails—and encourage responses,. Ask people for feedback. What do they like? What do they want more of? Why did they subscribe? Treat every response as an opportunity to deepen your relationship with your biggest fans. But remember to respond so they feel like there is a human at the other end of the email chain.
Mistake #10: Ignoring Consistency
Inconsistent email campaigns lack the momentum needed to build lasting relationships. If people only hear from you once every 30 days, your emails need to work a lot harder at reminding people why they subscribed to your newsletter in the first place. If you email less regularly than once a month, you open yourself up to higher unsubscribe rates and spam complaints.
What to Do Instead: Stick to a consistent schedule. Whether it’s a weekly newsletter or monthly updates, make sure your audience knows when to expect your emails—and deliver on that promise every single time.
đź“Ą Let’s Build a Lead Magnet
Want help creating a uniquely creative email marketing strategy? I offer short-term marketing services for cultural and destination marketers.
From content strategy to email marketing optimization, I’ll help you make your marketing work harder. Let’s talk → Book a Free Vision Call to discuss your marketing strategy.
Email Marketing Summary
Avoiding these common email marketing mistakes is key to building lasting, meaningful relationships with your audience. By focusing on personalization, consistency, and creating valuable content, you’ll not only enhance engagement but also foster loyalty among your subscribers. Making small adjustments can make a big difference in how effectively you connect with visitors, culture bearers, and stakeholders.
🔥 Free Download 🔥
Destination: Inbox
The essential guide to email marketing workbook for arts, heritage & hospitality organizations.
When funding dries up and algorithms shift, email marketing still delivers. This planner dives into how to build stronger relationships and nurture your list with purpose so you can drive more bookings and save valuable time every month.
You will also be subscribed to💥Let’s Make Some Noise💥– weekly marketing tips for creative and hospitality pros telling the story of place. Smarter marketing, without selling out. (Unsubscribe anytime.)
Book a Vision Call
Questions? Ready to get started? Book a free Vision Call to discuss your cultural tourism vision.
Book NowMore Email Marketing Articles
Build Your Email Strategy
Ready to transform your email marketing into a system that drives engagement, builds lasting relationships, and delivers real results? Learn more about our tailored Email Marketing for Arts & Tourism strategies that work with you to meet your goals.
Book Now